Week 12; April 4th-18th Blog Entry #4 (Done by S).

 When You Wish Upon a Star It Makes a Difference Who You Are

            Sleeping Beauty, Pocahontas, Belle, Cinderella, Ariel, Snow White and many other Disney princesses have had a powerful influence on informing the dreams of children for generations. What appear to be fun-filled stories of adventure and romance in fact are highly manipulative messages stemming from hegemonic influences of the dominance of one social group over another strategically incorporated into the Disney princess mythology (Aulette and Wittner 10). Disney princesses were used to teach girls their place within hierarchies including race, gender, ethnicity, sexuality and social class in their families and in western society; in happy heterosexual marriages, living in a stable class system with successful heroes who have wealth and power (Pearson 9). Receiving considerable criticism for perpetuating hegemonic masculinity, culturally exalted in male toughness and competition and the subordination of women there was much anticipation over the release of Frozen, Disney’s new film of 2013 (Aulette and Wittner 10).

            Frozen is based on Hans Christian Andersen’s story of The Snow Queen (Lemire). Directed by Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee released in November of 2013, Frozen tells a story of the power of sisterly love and embracing your true nature. A wild adventure occurs when Anna (Kristen Bell) enlists the orienteering skills of Kristoff (Jonathan Groff) in a race to find her sister Elsa (Idina Menzel) and release the kingdom of Arendelle from the deep freeze that Elsa’s powers have trapped it in. Through intersectional analysis of hegemonic influences in Frozen revealed in gender socialization, race, beauty and ableism this animated movie has subverted contentions of typical Disney princesses depicting strong female characters while holding onto some old baggage maximizing merchandising potential.

            Images of Disney heroes and heroines are dictated by hegemonic influences that exalt masculinity characterized by power, aggressiveness, strength and competition and emphasize femininity through the media version of womanhood (Aulette and Wittner 10). The relevance of this is the impact these characters have on the gender socialization of girls and boys as they learn their place in social systems (Pearson 3). Unlike traditional Disney films where the handsome prince rescues the princess and breaks the curse with true loves kiss, Frozen celebrates the power of familial love between sisters. Anna displays agency when she sets out alone to rescue her sister employing Kristoff as her mountain guide. Portraying a girl in an assertive role empowered by her own courage and ingenuity reflects a change to existing patterns and social practices (Aulette and Wittner 11). Devaluing women, portraying them in roles depicting subordination to men, where male strength or ingenuity is required to fix a problem perpetuates the social dominance of men (Tolmie Week 3 Lecture). In this way Disney begins to shift away from perceptions of established gender roles internalized by processes of gender socialization (Ibid). A definite step forward from the myriad of damsel in distress females of previous Disney films.

Image

             By creating a story with an unmistakable focus on the power of love and commitment between sisters the dominance of heterosexual romance in previous movies receives a gentle nudge. Addressing the superficiality and risk of instant betrothals from love-at-first-sight, reminiscent of previous Disney scenes, both Elsa and Kristoff reprimand Anna for accepting the engagement of a complete stranger. Alas, heterosexual love does rear it’s head throughout the movie because let’s be honest, romance sells and Disney’s not quite ready to totally change their recipe of success.

             Characters portrayed in Disney movies uphold the silence of race through promulgating whiteness. The lack of racial representation in Frozen cannot be completely explained by its geographical setting in Scandinavia. The presence of trolls, anthropomorphic snowmen and sentient reindeer negate arguments of adhering to cultural realism. There were in fact many opportunities for racial variance to be reflected in crowd scenes but they were not. Images of whiteness within Disney films reflects a complicity to perpetuate racial categories of hierarchy and superiority and a willingness to participate in creating disturbed forms of racial authority of the “west and the rest”  (Kothari 11). Even when Disney portrays such multicultural princesses as Jasmine, Pocahontas, Mulan and Tiana their features have been Anglicized away from true cultural representations retaining the silence of race and shaping notions of race within the minds of children (Ibrahim and Tolmie Week 8 Lecture).

             Images of beautiful, able-bodied princesses and heroes including characters in Frozen are the product of how society views individuals with disabilities (Pearson 67). The physical representation of slim fair skinned heroines with doe-shaped eyes, long, lustrous hair, ruby red lips, hyperbolized waists with tall, muscular and handsome Prince Charming’s illustrate western societies adherence to the social model of disability (Ibid). In week six readings Pearson states that disabled individuals can be “…feared, distrusted, pitied, overprotected, and patronized” (Ibid 66). Imagine Ariel in a wheelchair or Pocahontas on crutches, would that change their appeal? Italian artist Alexsandro Palombo has created illustrations of Disney’s princesses with missing limbs, seated in wheelchairs or leaning on crutches to highlight the prevalence of ablesim in pop culture (Murray). At best Disney takes a weak step in Frozen revealing a sleeping Anna with messy hair, mouth open and drool on her chin.

ImageImage

             Disney takes a few steps out of the past with Frozen. It even passes the Bechdel test; there are two females who engage in more than one conversation with each other that’s not about men (Sarkeesian). Is it perfect, does it completely break down barriers of hegemony? No, it doesn’t. It addresses some issues under the umbrella of gender socialization but falls short in race, beauty and ableism. Once past issues of intersectional analysis (and some eye rolling and cringing) I found myself totally immersed in the magic of Disney and rooting for the heroine! (not the hero!)
– S Entry.

Sources Used
– Aulette, Judy Root and Judith Wittner. Gendered Worlds: Second Edition. New York: Oxford University Press, 2012. Print.
An Agenda for Thinking about ‘Race’ in Development (Kothari) Link on Week 7.
– Eitzen D. Stanley, Maxine Baca Zinn, and Kelly Eitzen Smith. Gender, Race, and Popular Culture GNDS 125: Custom Edition for Queen’s University. Toronto: Pearson Learning Solutions, 2014. Print.
Frozen. Dir. Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee. Disney, 2013. Film.
– Lemire, Christy. “Frozen: Reviews.” Rogerebert [27 November 2013]: Online.
– Murray, Rheana. “Experts Applaud Artist’s Disabled Disney Princess Series.” New York Daily News [27 January 2014]: Online.
– Sarkeesian, Anita. “The Bechdel Test for Women in Movies.” Online video clip. YouTube. YouTube, 7 Dec. 2009. Web. 8 Apr. 2014.
– Tolmie, Jane. “Lecture #.” GNDS 125. Bioscience Auditorium. January – March 2014. Lecture.    
Pictures
– Disney’s Frozen Official Trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TbQm5doF_Uc
– Image 1: http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20131103205459/disney/images/6/66/Frozen_castposter.jpg
– Image 2:
http://images6.fanpop.com/image/photos/33600000/Disney-Princess-2013-official-line-up-disney-princess-33628221-1368-620.jpg
– Image 3:
http://media1.giphy.com/media/8GOYcHhgqwDkI/200_s.gif

Advertisements

3 Comments

  1. I found your analysis on the images of Disney heroes and heroines being dictated by hegemonic influences that exalt masculinity, power and agression very interesting. Until taking this course, i never really gave a second thought to the male-female dichotomy in regular, seemingly innocent movies. This dichotomy often perpetuates a damsel-in-distress scenario in which a strong male must save them. You’re right in your analysis on how this contributes to the gender socialization proces of both girls and boys, and how this tells them their place in social systems.
    I really like how you bring into the picture: sure, people are very attached to these characters now, but if they didn’t epitomize western beauty, would they be as beloved? you tackle this question head on in an intriguing manner.
    Ultimately, it would be a refreshing perspective to see disney stars in more real life scenarios, which might incude disabledness. I guess that’s not what the general public wants to see.
    – M

  2. Prior to reading your blog, I had never thought too much about the hierarchies of race, gender, ethnicity, sexuality and social class in Disney films. I got stuck on your first paragraph for a while as I played the classic Disney movies over in my head and thought about all the blatant messages I had missed. I have to say I am quite taken back by how effectively Disney essentially uses magic and glitter as a mask to it’s many deeply rooted stereotypes. While I’d like to think watching those movies as a child didn’t alter my and many others’ perceptions on anyone who isn’t white, able, and stereotypically ideal, the socializing powers films have is quite powerful. As for Frozen, I too think it veers away from the classic “Prince and Princess” Disney films. I thought it effectively showed the power young women should feel they have within themselves. Though yes, the film isn’t perfect and it does feature a predominately able, white, and upper class crowd, it did tackle the idea of female agency effectively. It would be a lot to ask of a film to address issues of gender, class, race, and hegemony all within a single plot.

    – J.

  3. Baby steps! I agree with you that Disney has begun to take steps towards a more realistic approach to what its characters would look like in real life situations. For example, Anna waking up with her hair a mess and drool running down her face when she woke up. I agree with your argument that Disney is still portraying its characters with the classis physical shapes while only changing the hair, shades of white skin, and eye colour, their previous few movies have become more diverse with the addition of red hair and African American character. The biggest positive change Disney has made, in my opinion, is the introduction of female agency and NOT having the man save a damsel in distress, but rather having the power of sisterly love being the climax and powerful point in the movie. Male dominance enforced through films?…Let It Go!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s